Jump to content

Good Year R430 Cantilever vs. Hoosier R45A Bias Tires


Pinnacle Racing

Recommended Posts

So the issue is this. I've run the Good Year Eagle G19 R430 Compound for a few years now and they work well on my 914-6 set up with the typical negative 1 degree of camber at all corners.

I just bought Hoosier Bias rains, and found out that Hoosier has a contingency for us. I never ran a Hoosier R45 or R35 Bias slick. Dimensions for my ride are the same. My concern is will the Hoosier give me similar performance and feel as the Good Year has. Good Year is also light at 18 lbs. mounted on my 15x8 Fuchs wheels.

I would like to take advantage of the contingency Hoosier is offering but not at a sacrifice. Any thoughts would be appreciated...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have raced on both Hoosiers and Goodyear's before, just not on a road course. However, I have been told their characteristics are pretty much the same with both variations. With that said, here is what you should expect:

 

Hoosiers: Faster than the Goodyear right out of the box, but won't last as long.

Goodyear: Consistant and longer lasting but not as fast as the Hoosier.

 

I know that what I said is pretty much self explanatory but it really depends on what you want out of a tire.

 

My experience with both tires btw were acquired at a little short track just east of you in Riverhead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok,

So can you answer this perhaps. The GY comes in a 250, 430 and 600 compound from soft to harder.

The Hoosier comes in a R35A, R45B, and R55A compound.

1- What compounds cross reference each other from GY to H.

2- Hoosier makes an A and a B in their designations. Does anyone know why and what they mean respectively?

Thanks in advance...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A's are older, not age of tire but issuance of compound, B's are the newer compound. The B compound is the newest compound...stickier and longer lasting. I would, and have, run the 45B most of the year. I would run the 35A in the colder early months of the year and the colder later months of the year. Also 35A's make great qualifying only compounds.

 

250 = R35A

430 = R45B

600 = R55B or A

 

 

PS I've yet to see any NASA competitors on Goodyear, the reason, no contingency from Goodyear. It stands to reason if you win on Goodyears you have beaten someone on Hoosiers. If you win on Hoosiers then you have beaten someone on Hoosiers and you win tires. The tires are so close that the car/driver will make the difference IMO. More SCCA guys race on Hoosiers and win, then race on Goodyears and win. The past June Sprints one week ago at Road America, almost 2 to 1 were on Hoosiers over Goodyear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More SCCA guys race on Hoosiers and win, then race on Goodyears and win. The past June Sprints one week ago at Road America, almost 2 to 1 were on Hoosiers over Goodyear.

 

As someone who is switching from the R6 to slicks soon, I have been looking into this same thing - H or GY. No GY contingency makes it obvious for NASA, but for SCCA both H and GY give out 2 tires for a win. It is my understanding that the opposite of what is posted above is true, at least for Prod cars. Don't a lot more of the Prod guys run GY than H?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More SCCA guys race on Hoosiers and win, then race on Goodyears and win. The past June Sprints one week ago at Road America, almost 2 to 1 were on Hoosiers over Goodyear.

 

As someone who is switching from the R6 to slicks soon, I have been looking into this same thing - H or GY. No GY contingency makes it obvious for NASA, but for SCCA both H and GY give out 2 tires for a win. It is my understanding that the opposite of what is posted above is true, at least for Prod cars. Don't a lot more of the Prod guys run GY than H?

 

 

In SCCA Prod.....it might be a little more bias toward Goodyear over the past few years. I think the split is probably 50 percent or pretty near close to that. As far as winners in SCCA I think there are more Goodyear winners, in Prod, at the high profile events. But it doesn't pay to run Goodyears in NASA .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...